Key Takeaways: Probating a will generally involves having the probate court determine whether the will is valid and admit it to probate so the deceased person’s estate can be administered.
- Proving a will requires establishing its validity. The court verifies the will was properly executed and that the person who made it had the mental capacity required to do so.
- A will may be admitted to probate or rejected. If the will is successfully proven, the court generally admits it to probate. However, the will may still be challenged, potentially resulting in its admission being revoked.
- The executor typically submits the will for probate. However, another interested party, such as a beneficiary or heir, may petition the court to probate the will if the named executor fails to act.
What Happens When a Will Is Probated in California?
In California, when a will is probated, it is submitted to the probate court so the judge can determine whether the document is valid and should be admitted to probate.
This process (known as “proving the will”) typically requires the court to determine whether the will was properly executed and whether the person who made it (called the testator) had the necessary mental capacity to do so.
Executing a will generally requires the testator to sign and date the will in the physical presence of at least two adult witnesses who are not beneficiaries. The witnesses must also sign the will while the testator is alive.
Testamentary capacity requires the testator to understand that they are making a will, the nature of their property, their familial relationships, and to be free from delusions that affect how they distribute their assets.
When a will is successfully proven, its admission to probate establishes it as the document governing the distribution of the decedent’s probate estate. This generally consists of assets the decedent owned solely in their name that do not otherwise transfer outside of probate.
Probating a will also provides interested parties, such as beneficiaries and heirs, with notice that a probate case has been opened and an opportunity to object to the will’s admission.
Once a will is admitted to probate, the estate can typically proceed with the remainder of the administration process, provided the will’s admission is not revoked following a successful challenge.
What Are the Potential Outcomes of Probating a Will in California? | ||
Potential Outcome | Why It May Happen | Effect on the Estate |
Will is admitted to probate | The court determines the will is valid, and no successful objections have been raised to prevent its admission. | The will becomes the governing document for distributing the decedent’s probate estate, and estate administration can proceed according to its terms. |
Will is denied admission to probate | The proponent of the will fails to establish the validity of the will, possibly owing to legitimate objections from interested parties, or proof of improper execution or a lack of testamentary capacity at the time of signing. | The will cannot be used to govern distribution of the estate. A prior valid will may be used instead, or distribution may be governed by California’s intestate succession laws, depending on the circumstances. |
Will is admitted but later successfully challenged | An interested party successfully challenges the will following its admission into probate on legally recognized grounds, such as undue influence, fraud, lack of capacity, improper execution, or mistake. | The court may revoke the will’s admission in whole or in part, depending on the circumstances. The estate may instead be distributed under a prior valid will or, if no will exists, under intestate succession laws. |
Will is admitted after an objection is resolved | An interested party contests the will, but the court ultimately determines that the objection does not prevent the document’s admission to probate. | The will remains the governing document, and the estate can proceed through administration according to its terms. |
Why Are Wills Probated in California?
In California, wills are typically probated to confirm their validity and provide interested parties with an opportunity to object to their admission if they believe the will does not accurately reflect the testator’s known wishes or is otherwise invalid.
If the court admits the will to probate, it generally means the court has determined that the will is valid and the authentic last will and testament of the deceased person. Provided the document is not later successfully challenged, it will govern the distribution of the decedent’s probate assets.
These generally include assets the decedent owned solely in their name that are not otherwise designated to transfer outside of probate through a mechanism such as a trust, payable-on-death (POD) or transfer-on-death (TOD) beneficiary designation.
Who Is Responsible for Probating a Will in California?
In California, the named executor is usually responsible for probating the will. Because they are merely a nominee until formally appointed by the court, they generally cannot be held personally liable for failing to initiate probate. They may, however, be deemed to have forfeited their right to serve if they wait too long to act.
If the named executor is also the custodian of the will, meaning the testator gave them the original will for safekeeping, they are responsible for lodging the will with the court within 30 days of learning of the testator’s death. They may be held liable for failing to do so if the delay causes harm to the estate or its beneficiaries.
If the named executor declines to serve or is otherwise unable to do so, another interested party, such as a beneficiary or heir, may petition the court to open probate and request appointment as the personal representative. The court will determine who should serve based on the circumstances of the estate and applicable state laws.
Probating a Will FAQs
Is probate necessary for all wills?
No, probate isn’t necessary for all wills. While California generally requires wills to be lodged with the court, whether a will must be probated typically depends on how estate assets are titled, the total value of the estate, and whether mechanisms are in place for transferring assets outside of probate.
If most assets are designated to transfer outside of probate, such as through a trust or beneficiary designation, probate can often be avoided. The same may be true if the estate qualifies for a simplified procedure, such as a Small Estate Affidavit, Petition to Determine Succession to Primary Residence, or Spousal Property Petition. However, probate may be required when an estate exceeds the current $208,850 small-estate threshold.
If you are unsure whether probate is necessary for a will, a probate attorney can review the will and estate to help determine the appropriate course of action.
What makes a will go into probate in California?
A will generally goes through probate in California when the deceased person owned assets solely in their name, the total value of those assets exceeds the current $208,850 small-estate threshold, and no mechanism is in place to transfer them outside of probate, such as a trust or beneficiary designation.
Even if an estate is exempt from mandatory probate, probating the will may still be necessary to resolve disputes or secure court intervention. For instance, the court may need to step in if someone challenges the will's validity, disputes who owns certain property, or requests guidance on how to interpret ambiguous will terms.
What are the disadvantages of probating a will?
Probating a will carries several distinct disadvantages, chiefly high costs and extended timelines.
In California, probate fees and creditor claims are generally prioritized over distributions, which can significantly reduce inheritances. Furthermore, the process can delay asset distribution to beneficiaries for nine to 12 months or longer. Because probate proceedings and wills are matters of public record, families also lose their privacy.
Despite these drawbacks, probate offers key advantages. Court supervision minimizes executor misconduct and administrative errors. Additionally, the public nature of the proceedings ensures transparency, allowing beneficiaries to track the process independently if an executor fails to communicate.
Is probate required if there is no will?
It usually depends on the estate's total value, how assets are titled, and whether mechanisms exist to transfer them outside of probate. Consequently, having no will has little effect on whether probate is required. In most cases, if the total value of the intestate estate exceeds California's $208,850 small-estate threshold, probate is necessary.
Even without a will to guide distribution, the probate process remains largely the same. However, instead of an executor, the court appoints an administrator. Similarly, assets go to legal heirs according to California’s intestate succession laws, rather than named beneficiaries according to the terms of the deceased person’s will.
Need help understanding probate? We can help provide clarity.
Learn how Keystone can help you navigate probating a will, or tell us about your situation below.
