In California, whether co-trustees can act independently depends on the trust’s terms. When the trust addresses co-trustee authority, its terms generally control. When the trust is silent, co-trustees generally must act unanimously.
- Disagreements can stall administration. Conflicts among co-trustees may cause delays, often resulting in unnecessary expenses for the trust, behind-schedule distributions to beneficiaries, and other consequences, making cooperation important.
- Co-trustees may share liability for losses. Even when a co-trustee has independent authority, all co-trustees may be personally liable for losses if they fail to take reasonable steps to prevent them, subject to certain exceptions.
- Noncooperative co-trustees may be removed. A court may remove a co-trustee if their conduct constitutes a breach of fiduciary duty, mismanagement, or other misconduct that interferes with proper trust administration.
When Can a Co-Trustee Act Alone?
In California, a co-trustee may act alone only when the trust expressly grants them independent authority. Otherwise, co-trustees generally are required to act jointly.
However, there are limited circumstances in which a co-trustee may be permitted to act alone even without express independent authority.
Common situations in which a co-trustee may have authority to act alone include:
- Explicit trust terms: A co-trustee may act alone when the trust terms expressly grant them independent authority.
- Delegated tasks: A co-trustee may act alone when they have been lawfully delegated certain nondiscretionary, routine, or specialized tasks, such as paying utility bills for trust properties, managing a trust checking account, or handling bookkeeping. The delegating trustee generally must continue to exercise reasonable oversight to avoid personal liability.
- Emergency situations: A co-trustee may act alone when a cotrustee is unavailable because of absence, illness, or other temporary incapacity to prevent harm to the trust.
- Vacancy: A co-trustee may be able to act alone when there is a vacancy in the office of the trustee, such as when a co-trustee resigns or dies, unless the instrument provides otherwise.
This list is not exhaustive, and other circumstances may permit a co-trustee to act alone. When questions arise about a co-trustee’s authority or disagreements prevent trust administration from moving forward, seeking guidance from the court or an experienced California trust attorney can help avoid potential personal liability.
Is Every Co-Trustee Required to Participate?
In California, each co-trustee generally has a duty to participate in the trust’s administration. A co-trustee typically cannot remain passive or entirely delegate all of their responsibilities to another co-trustee.
If a co-trustee is unable or unwilling to participate, they may want to consider declining the appointment before accepting it or resigning after becoming a trustee. Once the appointment is active, however, a co-trustee generally must fulfill their fiduciary duties and may face liability for failing to do so.
Do All Co-Trustees Have to Sign Trust Documents?
Whether all co-trustees must sign trust documents depends on the trust’s terms and whether it permits co-trustees to act independently. If the trust authorizes independent action, all co-trustees may not need to sign every document. Otherwise, joint action generally requires all co-trustees to sign.
There is an important caveat: Even when a co-trustee has independent authority, financial institutions and title companies may require all co-trustees to sign documents for major transactions, such as selling or transferring real estate or closing a bank account. As a result, having all co-trustees sign may be preferable even when their signatures are not technically required by the trust or law.
When Do Co-Trustees Have to Act Jointly?
Co-trustees generally must act jointly when the trust is silent about how co-trustees may exercise their powers. In other words, when the trust expressly addresses co-trustee authority, its terms generally control. When it does not, California’s default rule requires co-trustees to act unanimously.
This rule is clearly reflected in the California Probate Code, which states:
“Unless otherwise provided in the trust instrument, a power vested in two or more trustees may only be exercised by their unanimous action.”
Although certain routine, nondiscretionary tasks may potentially be delegated from one co-trustee to another, co-trustees generally must act jointly when exercising discretionary powers or making decisions that affect their fiduciary duties.
Examples of decisions that may require joint action include:
- Buying or selling trust assets
- Making investments using trust funds
- Hiring or firing third-party professionals
- Bringing or defending legal claims involving the trust
Importantly, unanimous action is not the only way a trust may structure co-trustee decision-making. A trust may, for example, authorize a majority to make decisions when three or more co-trustees disagree. In certain circumstances, a court may also provide a mechanism for resolving a deadlock when co-trustee disagreements have stalled trust administration.
Ultimately, co-trustees should understand the scope of their authority and any conditions placed on it. Acting outside that authority can result in a breach of the trust’s terms or their fiduciary duties.
Is a Co-Trustee Liable for Another Trustee’s Actions?
A co-trustee may be held liable for another trustee’s actions, even if they did not directly participate in the misconduct. A trustee’s fiduciary duties generally include taking reasonable steps to prevent or address a co-trustee’s breach when they become aware of it.
A co-trustee may be liable for another trustee’s actions when they:
- Participated in the breach. The co-trustee was also involved in committing the breach of fiduciary duty.
- Failed to prevent or address a breach. The co-trustee failed to take reasonable steps to prevent a breach or address it where the trustee knows, or should have known, about the breach.
- Concealed the breach. The co-trustee actively hid or acquiesces in another trustee’s misconduct.
- Failed to supervise a delegated task. The co-trustee delegated a task to another trustee but failed to exercise adequate oversight.
- Negligently enabling a breach. The co-trustee negligently monitors the actions of their co-trustee, enabling a breach.
In other words, co-trustees generally cannot ignore misconduct simply because they did not personally commit it. Even when a trustee has independent authority, other co-trustees may have a duty to take reasonable action to protect the trust and its beneficiaries.
For example, suppose one co-trustee misappropriates trust assets. Even if that trustee had independent authority to manage certain trust assets, that authority would not permit them to use trust property for personal purposes. If another co-trustee becomes aware of the misconduct, or should have been aware of it with reasonable diligence, but fails to take reasonable steps to address it, that co-trustee could potentially be held liable for resulting losses and required to reimburse the trust from their own pockets.
What Happens When Co-Trustees Disagree?
When co-trustees disagree, trust administration can reach a stalemate, delaying or preventing important decisions. This can have practical consequences, such as behind-schedule distributions to beneficiaries and unnecessary expenses for the trust.
Disagreements among co-trustees are not necessarily problematic. Occasional differences of opinion are normal. However, when disagreements persist without resolution, harm the trust, or bring administration to a standstill, more decisive action may be necessary.
How to Handle Co-Trustee Disagreements
When co-trustees are unable to agree, the following steps may help resolve the dispute:
- Consult the trust terms. A trust may include specific procedures for resolving disagreements among co-trustees. If so, those provisions generally should be followed. For example, the trust may permit a majority vote or give one trustee authority to make the final decision.
- Seek legal guidance. A trust attorney can review the trust terms and applicable California trust laws to clarify how the dispute should be handled and recommend potential strategies for resolving it.
- Consider mediation. A neutral mediator can help co-trustees communicate, negotiate, and potentially reach a compromise that allows administration to move forward.
- Ask the dissenting trustee to resign. If one co-trustee is preventing administration from moving forward, the other trustees or beneficiaries may ask them to resign. The decision ultimately rests with the trustee, but the request may provide an opportunity to resolve the impasse without court intervention.
- Petition the probate court. If other efforts fail, the co-trustees may petition the court for instructions on how to proceed. Depending on the circumstances, the court may authorize certain action without the dissenting trustee’s consent or provide another mechanism for resolving the deadlock. If a co-trustee’s conduct warrants removal, that may also be appropriate to request. However, a trustee generally cannot be removed simply because of a minor disagreement or personality clash; there must be a legally recognized basis for removal.
Co-Trustees Acting Independently FAQs
How many trustees can you have in a trust?
There generally is no limit to how many trustees a trust can have. However, naming multiple trustees can create practical challenges, including disagreements that stall administration or strain family relationships.
On the other hand, multiple trustees can offer important benefits, such as having more than one person review trust documents and decisions, dividing the administrative workload, and providing checks and balances.
Ultimately, the trust creator should consider their family dynamics and surrounding circumstances when deciding how many trustees to name. For example, naming children who have a history of conflict as co-trustees may create challenges. Alternatively, naming a family member and a private professional fiduciary as co-trustees may provide a balance between family involvement and professional oversight.
What constitutes an independent trustee in California?
In California, an independent trustee is generally a person or entity that manages a trust without having a financial or beneficial interest in it. Because the trustee does not have a personal stake in the trust, they can provide a degree of neutrality when making decisions.
It is important to distinguish an independent trustee from a trustee with independent authority, as the terms describe different concepts. A co-trustee with independent authority is someone whom the trust or court has authorized to act unilaterally on certain matters. That trustee may or may not be independent, depending on whether they have a personal interest in the trust.
Does a co-trustee own trust property?
A co-trustee may hold legal title to trust property, meaning their name may appear on the title. However, trustees do not have the same rights as ordinary property owners. They hold and manage trust property for the benefit of the beneficiaries and must follow the trust’s terms and applicable fiduciary duties.
A trustee may make decisions about trust property, such as whether to repair, sell, or transfer it, but their authority is subject to limitations.
For example, if the trust prohibits the sale of certain property, the trustee generally must follow that restriction. Similarly, a sale may be improper if it would harm the beneficiaries’ interests, such as selling property for substantially less than its fair market value. An individual who owns property outright, by contrast, generally has much broader discretion over how to use, sell, or transfer it.
Does a co-trustee have any power on their own?
A co-trustee may have authority to act independently if the trust expressly grants them that authority. Depending on the circumstances, a court may also authorize a co-trustee to act independently in certain situations.
If the trust is silent about co-trustee authority, however, California law generally requires co-trustees to act unanimously. This is particularly important when making major or discretionary decisions or taking actions involving their fiduciary duties.
Can a co-trustee be removed from a trust?
Yes, a co-trustee may be removed when there is a legal basis for removal. Generally, a petition must be filed with the court identifying the specific conduct supporting removal and explaining how that conduct has harmed the trust or its beneficiaries.
Importantly, a co-trustee typically cannot be removed simply because of personality conflicts, family rivalries, or disagreements over how the trust should be administered. Evidence of a breach of fiduciary duty, mismanagement, or other conduct that provides a legal basis for removal is usually necessary.
If removal of a trustee is being considered because a co-trustee is refusing to cooperate, mediation or asking the trustee to resign may provide alternatives to court intervention. Resolving the dispute without litigation can also help preserve trust assets that otherwise may be spent on legal fees.
Is it a good idea to have co-trustees in a trust?
Whether having co-trustees is a good idea generally depends on the trust creator’s circumstances, family dynamics, and goals for the trust. It can also come down to personal preference.
For some, having the trust administered as quickly and efficiently as possible may be the priority. In these cases, naming co-trustees can create opportunities for disagreements that delay or stall administration. For others, family involvement, oversight, and checks and balances may be more important. Naming co-trustees can help ensure that no single trustee has unchecked authority.
Ultimately, both approaches have potential benefits and drawbacks, and what works well for one trust may not be appropriate for another. If you are unsure which approach is right for you, an experienced estate planning attorney can discuss your goals and concerns and help you determine an arrangement that fits your circumstances.
How does a co-trustee sign?
In California, a co-trustee generally should sign trust documents using their full legal name, fiduciary title, the name of the trust, and the trust’s date.
For example, if John Smith is serving as co-trustee of the Jane Smith Family Trust dated August 10, 2020, he would generally sign documents as follows:
“John Smith, as Co-Trustee of the Jane Smith Family Trust dated August 10, 2020”
Struggling to understand co-trustee authority? We can help.
Learn how Keystone Law helps co-trustees navigate and understand their legal authority, or tell us about your situation below.