If a distribution to a beneficiary has come due, the executor generally cannot withhold it.
You’ll know a distribution is due if you’ve received a final accounting and notice of petition for final distribution. Once the court approves these documents, the executor is authorized to begin distributing the estate.
How long does an executor have to pay beneficiaries? It’s typical for payments to begin within two to four weeks of the court signing the order authorizing the distribution of assets — though this can vary depending on the size and complexity of the estate.
While a short delay isn’t necessarily cause for alarm, an executor taking more time than is reasonably necessary is a violation of their fiduciary duty to make timely distributions. If you’ve waited longer than expected, and the executor isn’t offering clear updates, it may be time to take legal action.
Too often, an executor not paying beneficiaries on time is a sign of mismanagement — or worse, executor misconduct. And the longer the delay, the harder it may become to recover your rightful inheritance, especially if estate funds are being misused or mishandled.
That said, there are situations where withholding money from a beneficiary is legally justified. In this article, we’ll explore when an executor may have the right to delay a distribution — and when they absolutely cannot. We’ll also go over steps you can take if an executor of a will is refusing to pay beneficiaries in a timely manner.
Dealing with a problematic trustee? Discover what to do when a trustee is not paying beneficiaries.
When Is Withholding Inheritance Legal?
An executor withholding an inheritance from a beneficiary is only legal if the distribution hasn’t yet come due. This typically means the final accounting and petition for final distribution have either not been filed with the court, are still pending approval or are under dispute. Once the court approves the distribution, the executor is required to make the payment as promptly as possible.
That said, not all distributions are quick or simple. While cash in a bank account may be easy to divide among beneficiaries, other assets — such as real estate — could take more time. For instance, if a decedent’s three children are each set to inherit a separate condo unit, the executor may need to prepare and file three separate deeds and ensure proper transfers of title, which can be a time-consuming process.
Below, we outline several valid reasons why an executor might withhold an inheritance from a beneficiary temporarily. However, it’s important to understand that these are reasons for delays — not indefinite withholding. If your inheritance is being delayed without explanation or seems unnecessarily prolonged, it may be time to seek legal guidance.
Unpaid Taxes or Debts
An executor has the authority — and legal obligation — to delay distributions in order to pay the decedent’s unpaid taxes and settle creditor claims. In fact, under California law, executors must resolve the estate’s debts before making any distributions to beneficiaries.
For beneficiaries, this can mean receiving a reduced inheritance — or, in some cases, no inheritance at all — if the decedent died with significant debt. If the estate’s liabilities outweigh its assets, there may be little left to distribute once creditors are paid.
According to California Probate Code Section 9100, creditors have a limited window to file claims against an estate. They must do so within four months of the executor’s formal appointment or within 60 days of receiving notice of the estate administration — whichever date comes later. Regardless of whether probate has been opened, all creditor claims must be filed within one year of the decedent’s death, or they are forever barred.
Estate beneficiaries have the right to stay informed about the creditor claim process by reviewing the accountings provided by the executor. These accountings must be shared at least once a year while the estate is open, unless the beneficiaries have waived that right in writing. Beneficiaries can also request updates from the executor about any claims filed and whether they’ve been paid.
In summary, creditor claims can cause delays in distributing the estate, but these delays are generally limited in duration. Once probate is opened, the creditor claim process might briefly slow things down — typically for four months or slightly longer — but once the legal deadlines pass, claims can no longer be filed.
That said, even after creditor issues are resolved, other factors, such as legal disputes, may continue to hold up distributions.
Will Disputes
When a will appears inconsistent with the decedent’s known intentions or contains vague or ambiguous language, it can trigger litigation — delaying the distribution of the estate.
Consider, for example, a situation in which a decedent’s will contains unusual provisions: It disinherits close family members and instead leaves the entire estate to distant acquaintances. The decedent’s family, aware that he suffered a serious stroke shortly before creating the will, believes he lacked the mental capacity required to execute it. As a result, they opt to contest the will.
In such cases, it’s clear why distributions may be delayed. If the validity of the entire will is in question, the executor cannot begin distributing assets until the matter is resolved — either via the settlement process or a court trial.
Now, imagine a different scenario: A decedent’s will states that her “children” should inherit her home, but doesn’t clarify whether this includes stepchildren or only biological children. In cases involving ambiguous terms like this one, the executor must file a petition for instructions with the probate court to determine the proper interpretation.
It’s important to recognize that ambiguities and will contests can take time to resolve. Occasionally, ambiguities can be clarified by referencing other language within the will, but if no such language exists, the court may need to consider extrinsic evidence to determine the decedent’s intent — a process that can be lengthy and complex.
If a will dispute is likely to cause significant delays, the executor may seek court approval to make partial distributions. This can only occur if the disputed portion of the estate is withheld, the undisputed assets are distributed fairly, and no objections are raised by the other beneficiaries.
Property Disputes
When questions of ownership or use arise regarding property included in an estate, the executor may need to delay distributions — or at least withhold the portion of the estate tied to the disputed property — until the issue is resolved.
For example, suppose a relative of the decedent claims that several valuable pieces of their jewelry were wrongfully taken by the decedent before their passing. They file an 850 petition to recover the items, asserting legal ownership. In this scenario, the executor cannot distribute the jewelry according to the will until the court determines who its rightful owner is.
The reason is clear: If the executor distributes the contested items before the 850 petition is resolved, and the court later rules in favor of the claimant, the executor may no longer be in possession of the property — and could be held personally liable for failing to safeguard assets that are subject to a legal dispute.
Regardless of the nature of the conflict, property disputes within an estate can significantly delay distributions, particularly when specific assets are involved. Executors must exercise caution and seek legal guidance to ensure they’re complying with their fiduciary duties while the matter is pending.
Beneficiary Misconduct
In rare but serious circumstances, an executor may petition the court to delay or withhold a beneficiary’s inheritance — especially if there is evidence that the beneficiary caused harm to the estate or engaged in misconduct to increase their inheritance.
For example, imagine a beneficiary has been secretly living in an estate property and hosting parties there, causing significant damage. As a result, the executor must use estate funds to make repairs before the property can be sold — costs that would not have existed otherwise. In such a case, the executor may have a fiduciary duty to the other beneficiaries to ask the court to withhold that individual’s inheritance to cover the losses they caused.
How Long Can an Executor Withhold Money From a Beneficiary?
There is no exact deadline by which an executor must pay beneficiaries, but they are legally required to distribute estate assets within a reasonable timeframe. Typically, this occurs within two to four weeks after the court grants approval for the final distribution.
That said, the timeline can vary depending on the complexity and size of the estate. If significant debts need to be resolved, or if disputes arise, distributions may be delayed. Still, if weeks have passed without any communication from the executor explaining the holdup, it’s valid to be concerned. In such cases, beneficiaries should consider consulting a fiduciary misconduct attorney to explore their legal options and ensure the executor is fulfilling their duties.
Can an Executor Not Pay a Beneficiary?
An executor does not have the authority to withhold a beneficiary’s inheritance simply because they want to. If a person is named in a valid will and their inheritance is not contingent upon any conditions — such as another beneficiary passing away before them — they are entitled to receive what the will provides. Executors cannot decide who gets what based on personal discretion; they must carry out the terms of the will as written.
However, there are situations in which beneficiaries may not receive their inheritance — not because of the executor’s discretion, but because the estate lacks sufficient funds. If creditor claims, taxes or administration costs have depleted the estate, the executor may not be able to pay beneficiaries at all.
In these cases, beneficiaries should closely examine the executor’s accountings to confirm the estate truly has been exhausted. If questions arise about the accuracy of the accountings or the handling of estate funds, seeking help from an experienced probate attorney is strongly recommended.
What if the Executor of a Will Refuses to Pay Beneficiaries?
An executor does not have the authority to refuse payment to beneficiaries if distributions have come due and there are sufficient funds remaining in the estate to pay them. While executors do have broad discretion in handling administrative matters, they ultimately are fiduciaries whose role is to carry out the terms of the will — not to make arbitrary decisions about who receives what.
If you’re entitled to an inheritance and a considerable amount of time has passed without payment or adequate explanation, it may be time to take more formal action. Below are several steps beneficiaries can take when faced with an executor who is withholding or delaying a distribution.
1. Ask the Executor for the Status of Your Inheritance
If an executor is not communicating with beneficiaries, it may be necessary for the beneficiaries to initiate contact to request updates. The best approach is to make your request in writing, as this creates a clear paper trail that can serve as evidence if the situation escalates.
Be specific in your request. For example, ask when you can expect to receive your inheritance, what might be causing the delay, and whether there are any pending issues holding up the process. The more detailed your communication, the better positioned you’ll be if you need to prove the executor failed to fulfill their obligations.
2. Create a Log of your Correspondence with the Executor
From the moment you suspect an unnecessary delay or misconduct, begin documenting every interaction with the executor. Maintain a log that includes dates, methods of communication (email, phone call, letter), the nature of your inquiry, and the executor’s responses — or lack thereof.
This log can become a critical piece of evidence if you need to take legal action. Courts often look for patterns of behavior, and a well-maintained record of unanswered inquiries or vague responses can help establish that the executor is not acting in good faith or fulfilling their duties as required by law.
3. Consult a Probate Attorney
If your written requests yield no meaningful updates or if you’re receiving evasive or inconsistent responses, it’s wise to consult an experienced probate attorney, who can review your situation and advise you on how to proceed.
This may include filing a petition to compel communication or distributions, or — if necessary — seeking the executor’s removal and replacement.
4. Take Legal Action
Often, retaining an attorney is enough to prompt an uncooperative executor to act — especially when they realize they may be held accountable in court.
However, if the executor continues to delay or withhold your inheritance without cause, your attorney can file a formal petition with the probate court. They will advocate on your behalf throughout the process to help ensure you receive the inheritance you’re legally entitled to.
FAQs: Executor Not Paying Beneficiaries
If you still are confused about when an executor can withhold money from beneficiaries — and when they can’t — have a look at the frequently asked questions below. For personalized legal guidance, don’t hesitate to reach out to our firm.
Does an executor have to notify beneficiaries of distributions?
Yes, once all estate disputes have been resolved and debts have been paid, the executor is required to file a final accounting and a petition for final distribution with the probate court. These documents must also be served to all the beneficiaries — even those who previously waived their right to receive accountings.
The documents outline how the estate will be distributed, including the amount and type of assets each beneficiary will receive, as well as any reductions due to debts, taxes or administrative costs.
If an executor fails to provide this required notice or distributes assets before the court has approved the final documents, they could be held personally liable for any accounting discrepancies or improper distributions.
Beneficiaries also have the right to challenge the accounting or the distribution plan if it appears incomplete or inaccurate, which may cause delays until the matter is resolved.
Can an executor of a will remove a beneficiary?
No, beneficiaries cannot be removed by the executor under any circumstance. Their role is limited to administering the estate in accordance with the terms of the will. They cannot override the decedent’s wishes or make changes to who inherits.
Any attempt to remove a beneficiary would be considered misconduct and could result in the executor being removed or facing legal consequences.
Can a beneficiary sue an executor for their inheritance?
Yes. If a distribution is due and the executor is withholding it without a valid legal reason, a beneficiary can take legal action. This typically involves filing a petition to compel the executor to make the distribution. If the court finds that the executor is unjustifiably delaying or denying payment, they may order the distribution and potentially penalize the executor.
Can an executor hide money from a beneficiary?
Absolutely not. Executors are fiduciaries, which means they must act with honesty and transparency. While they aren’t required to report every action in real time, they must provide periodic accountings that detail all financial activity related to the estate. Hiding money from a beneficiary would be a serious breach of fiduciary duty.
If there’s any indication that an executor is concealing assets or mismanaging estate funds, beneficiaries should speak with an experienced probate attorney immediately. These situations often point to larger problems that may require court intervention.
Can an executor withhold money from a beneficiary if the will allows it?
Yes, under limited circumstances. If the will includes a specific clause that permits the executor to withhold a beneficiary’s inheritance under certain conditions — such as substance abuse, financial irresponsibility or mental health concerns — the executor may be permitted to follow those instructions.
However, even in these cases, the executor must proceed carefully. Before withholding funds, it’s wise for them to consult a probate attorney to ensure they are interpreting the will correctly and acting within the bounds of the law. Missteps in this area could expose the executor to liability.
Still have questions about when an executor can withhold money?
Wondering if the executor is authorized to withhold your inheritance? If you’re facing delays or silence from the executor, you don’t have to navigate the situation alone. The probate attorneys at Keystone have extensive experience holding executors accountable and ensuring beneficiaries receive the inheritance they’re entitled to.
Contact us today. We can help you understand your rights, determine whether the executor is acting within the law, and take swift action if they’re not.
